A knowledge compilation perspective on queries and transformations for belief tracking
Résumé
Nondeterministic planning is the process of computing plans or policies of actions achieving given goals, when there is nondeterministic uncertainty about the initial state and/or the outcomes of actions. This process encompasses many precise computational problems, from classical planning, where there is no uncertainty, to contingent planning, where the agent has access to observations about the current state. Fundamental to these problems is belief tracking, that is, obtaining information about the current state after a history of actions and observations. At an abstract level, belief tracking can be seen as maintaining and querying the current belief state, that is, the set of states consistent with the history. We take a knowledge compilation perspective on these processes, by defining the queries and transformations which pertain to belief tracking. We study them for propositional domains, considering a number of representations for belief states, actions, observations, and goals. In particular, for belief states, we consider explicit propositional representations with and without auxiliary variables, as well as implicit representations by the history itself; and for actions, we consider propositional action theories as well as ground PDDL and conditional STRIPS. For all combinations, we investigate the complexity of relevant queries (for instance, whether an action is applicable at a belief state) and transformations (for instance, revising a belief state by an observation); we also discuss the relative succinctness of representations. Though many results show an expected tradeoff between succinctness and tractability, we identify some interesting combinations. We also discuss the choice of representations by existing planners in light of our study.
Domaines
Informatique [cs]| Origine | Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s) |
|---|